The following
description for has been prepared entirely by the current owner, Roberts S.
Fastov, Esq., and, at the
collector’s request, has not been edited by Sloans & Kenyon
Note
1) The following Kleitsch biographical materials are based on information taken
from the Askart.com website: Note 3) Born in Hungary, and after taking art
lessons in Budapest and painting the portrait of Kaiser Franz Joseph I head of
the then powerful Austro-Hungarian Empire, he went to Germany and came to the
U.S. in 1901, first settling in Cincinnati, Ohio. Per Askart.com: “In 1905 he
moved to Denver. Between 1907 and 1909 he visited and painted in Chicago,
Kansas and Mexico City. He was honored in 1912 for his portraits of Mexico's
President Francisco Madero and his family….Around 1914 Kleitsch moved to
Chicago where besides painting portraits of many prominent citizens, he taught
at the Art Institute of Chicago from 1914 to 1919. While there he joined the
Palette and Chisel Club and participated in exhibitions where his new style of
painting interior scenes with figures was shown. In 1914 he was awarded the
Gold Medal by the Art Institute of Chicago….In 1920 Joseph and his wife, Edna,
moved to Laguna Beach and started the Kleitsch Academy” and engaged in painting
his highly popular and now very valuable Impressionist views of gardens,
flowers, houses and scenes around Laguna Beach and other California venues,
with trips to Europe, until his premature death at age 49 as a result of a
heart attack in Santa Ana, CA on Nov. 16, 1931.
Kleitsch
exhibited with Stendahl Gallery, Los Angeles from 1922-1929, the Art Institute
of Chicago (1914 Gold Medal), Painters & Sculptors of LA, 1922-23;
Leonard's (LA), 1923; Ambassador Hotel (LA), 1924; Biltmore Salon (LA), 1924;
Ebell Club (LA), 1924; PAFA, 1925; Pasadena Public Library, 1928; Laguna Beach
AA, 1928-30; LACMA, 1933 (memorial). He also won prizes and awards as follows:
Gold Medal, Palette and Chisel Club, Silver Medal, Painters and Sculptors Club,
First Prize, California State Fair; and Grand Prize & Figure Prize, Laguna
Beach Art Association. His work is in the following museum collections: Bowers
Museum, Santa Ana, Laguna Art Museum, Laguna Beach and Irvine Museum, Irvine,
all of California, Colorado History Museum, Denver, Colorado; Fleischer
Museum, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Note
2): What distinguishes this portrait of a man from other Kleitsch male
portraits that have come on the market and makes it extremely valuable is: a) Its
historical significance, in terms of Kleitsch's oeuvre. It is arguable that
Kleitsch's painting's primary inspiration and focal point is not the man
depicted in the portrait, but rather the profusion, indeed, a sea of
Impressionistically painted beautiful brightly-colored pastel flowers, that he
decided to surround, indeed, imbed the man. He also painted the man's face and
body using a soft and subtle Impressionistic technique. This painting is
a very early and probably highly experimental Kleitsch venture into
Impressionist painting. That he responded so positively and emotionally to
the flowers and made them the dominant aspect of this painting foreshadows his
move to California to be among and paint these kinds of flowers and employ the
Impressionistic style for which he became a famous and very valuable California
artist. It is a work of 1918 done in Chicago, and is totally inconsistent
with his relatively realistic portraits that he generated in Chicago. See,
e.g.:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
As
this offering of Mr. Fastov's California art collection, including the painting
by Armin Hansen, should make clear, he is very interested in and knowledgeable
about California art and artists. Mr. Fastov purchased this painting at Quinn's
Auction Galleries, Falls Church, VA on 9/13/2008. Prior to bidding on this
painting, he did extensive research on Kleitsch and his oeuvre, including
reviewing all Kleitsch auction records and all of the reproductions of
Kleitsch's paintings on Google.com Images website, which are very extensive, as
they also include the numerous Kleitsch paintings that had been offered or were
being offered by art dealers and institutional owner's or borrowers of
Kleitsch's art and read all the biographical text on Kleitsch that he could obtain.
Having done this, Mr. Fastov, in essence, analyzed carefully the implications
of his research and, in effect, made all of the observations and drew all of
the conclusions expressed above and decided to make a serious effort at
purchasing the Kleitsch painting at Quinn's by exceeding if necessary, Quinn
Auction Galleries high estimate of $5,000. If a discerning collector of or
dealer in Kleitsch or in California Impressionism and/or reads Mr. Fastov's
foregoing analysis and conclusions and carefully evaluates them, he or she
should recognize that this painting is worth far more than the $5,000 and that
above estimates of $75,000-$150,000 are very reasonable and may well be
understated given Mr. Fastov's above observations and analysis; and should
pursue vigorously bidding to obtain this painting, which is a riot of
Impressionist coloring and technique in surrounding and embedding a figure in
an Impressionist sea of brightly colored pastel flowers, which Kleitsch, to the
best of Mr. Fastov's knowledge, has never come close to replicating in any
Kleitsch painting, of which Mr. Fastov is aware, and may be unique in his
oeuvre in this regard.
Note
3) Another slightly different perspective on this Kleitsch painting is offered.
This large Kleitsch painting manifests a combination the best of Kleitsch’s
favorite and best subjects, plein-air, highly keyed and multi-colored pastel
Impressionist garden and flower scenes with human figures and portraits. As is
stated in one of the Askart.com Kleitsch biographies: “He has been
characterized as a “master of gorgeous color.” Arthur Millier, art critic for
the “Los Angeles Times”, in 1933, said of Kleitsch that he was “a born
colorist; he seemed to play on canvas with the abandon of a gypsy violinist.”
Such abandon is clearly manifest in Kleitsch’s decision to present the
blue-robed figure in this painting amidst and embedded in a profusion and sea
of Impressionist bright multi-colored pastel flowers in this painting.
Moreover, this painting is clearly a precursor of Kleitsch’s Impressionist
paintings of Laguna Beach, which manifested and celebrated, according to
Anthony Anderson, an art critic of the Los Angeles Times in 1922, “gardens
rioting in bloom.” Indeed, this painting signals why Kleitsch decided to remove
himself to Laguna Beach, and its beautiful gardens and flowers in 1920. Indeed,
the wistful look on the man’s face, suggests that Kleitsch, himself, really
desires to be able to embed himself in such flowers and make them the subject
of his paintings 365 days a year in sunny California.
Note
4) The foregoing considerations and the following auction records regarding
Kleitsch sales, which provide additional support for the presale estimate of
$75,000-$150,000 and warrant the conclusion that the presale estimate of
$75,000-$150,000 is reasonable and justifiable and that the high estimate of
$150,000 is very conservative given the foregoing considerations, including the
fact that this Kleitsch auction painting is much larger than some of the
Kleitsch paintings which brought more than $150,000, which are smaller than the
28 ¼ in. x 33 ¾ in. dimensions of this Kleitsch auction painting. See, e.g.,
the above described painting sales of “A Conversation in a Mission Garden, 1924
and Woman in a garden sewing. Moreover, the auction price brought by some of
the Kleitsch larger paintings is so great and the relatively small disparity
between the size of the larger painting and this Kleitsch auction painting
compels a conclusion that the proportionate size of this Kleitsch auction
painting is sufficient to cause the person preparing the high estimate to
factor in and take account of a significant percentage of the very high auction
price obtained for the larger painting in establishing the high presale
estimate for the Kleitsch auction painting. See below, e.g., the Kleitsch
painting entitled “Highlights,” which measured 38.25 in. x 46.25 in., and
recently sold for $506,000. The case for increasing both the low and high
presale estimates for this Kleitsch auction painting to amounts in excess of
$75,000 low estimate and $150,000 high estimate is even clearer when a Kleitsch
painting that is smaller than this Kleitsch auction painting, and the smaller
painting brings an amount in excess of the $150,000 high estimate. See below,
e.g., the Kleitsch painting entitled “Garden at Capistrano,” which measured 22 in.
x 27 in., and sold for $230,000.
|
||||
|
|
Title/Subject: Tangled Branches, Laguna Canyon Signed. Oil on canvas. 23
in. x 17 in. sold for $93,250 on 12/12/2005 at Bonhams
& Butterfields, San Francisco, CA Title/Subject: A View of a French Village, 1926 Signed. Oil on canvas.
23 in. x 23 in. sold for $99,000 on 08/08/2005 at Bonhams & Butterfields, San Francisco, CA Title/Subject: Roses in glass vase Signed. Oil on canvas. 18 in. x 21
in. sold for $138,000 on 06/21/2005 at John Moran Auctioneers, Altadena, CA Title/Subject: Grey Symphony Signed. Oil on canvas. 16 in. x 20 in. sold
for $92,000 on 06/21/2005 at John Moran Auctioneers, Altadena, CA Title/Subject: Mission Canyon Signed. Oil on canvas. 29 in. x 33 in.
sold for $108,000 on 04/27/2005 at Christie’s, Los Angeles, CA Title/Subject: Pala Mission California Signed. Oil on canvas. 14.25 in.
x 16.50 in. sold for $70,630 on 02/15/2005 at John Moran Auctioneers,
Altadena, CA Title/Subject: San Juan Capristrano Signed. Oil on canvas. 16.20 in. x 20.20
in. sold for $68,880 on 06/09/2002 at Bonhams
& Butterfields, San Francisco, CA Title/Subject: Park Avenue, Old Laguna Signed. Oil on canvas. 36 in. x
40 in. sold for $336,000 on 11/07/2001 at Christie’s, Los Angeles, CA |