The following
description for has been prepared entirely by the current owner, Roberts S.
Fastov, Esq., and, at the collector’s request, has not been edited by Sloans
& Kenyon
Charles Willson Peale
(Maryland/Pennsylvania 1741-1827) Portrait of a handsome Pennsylvania Quaker
woman, c. 1810, at age c. 35 to 40 years old. Oil on canvas. 24 in. x 20 in.
Estimate: $30,000-$50,000. Provenance: Daniel Hersh, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
area
Note
1) That this woman was a Quaker is made manifest by her simple Quaker attire,
which distinguishes this portrait from the more fashionable women that Peale
painted. This was confirmed when Mr. Fastov showed this painting to Lillian B.
Miller, Editor of The Selected Papers Of Charles Willson Peale And His Family
and Historian of American Culture, National Portrait Gallery, several years
ago, she suggested that this portrait was painted when Peale visited some of
his wife's Quaker female friends, c. 1812. In a letter dated February 9, 1987,
she stated the portrait “may be of a Quaker friend of his third wife Hannah
Moore Peale in Germantown, whom he notes in his farm book around 1812 that he
was setting out to paint.” She also noted that Peale never disclosed “the name
of the sitter,” but she was relatively young and attractive. Peale married his
3rd wife, Hannah Moore, a Quaker, in 1805.
Charles Willson Peale’s likeness of his third wife, Hannah
Moore (1755-1821), whom he married in 1805, depicts his respect for and
admiration for his then 61 year old wife, who was clearly a very handsome
woman, when she was younger. Among other reasons for Peale so respecting and
admiring Hannah is because Hannah helped raise
Peale's children from his previous two marriages and did so in a very effective
manner, judging by the incredible success of Peale's artist children. The key
consideration, however, is that if one compares the portrait of the Quaker
woman that is up for auction with that of Hannah Peale, one cannot doubt that
the same hand, the hand of Charles Willson Peale, executed the portrait of the
Quaker woman, even though she is more youthful and attractive than the 61 year
old Hannah Peale. Without doubt, there is no other early 19th
century American portrait painter whose style and technique would have permitted
him to execute this portrait of a Quaker woman, including artists such leading
portrait artists such as Gilbert Stuart and John Wesley Jarvis, or any of the
other lesser American portraitists. The Peale style and technique manifested in
the portrait of the Quaker woman is foreshadowed in the following Peale
portrait of his mother, painted earlier in 1770.
Margaret Triggs Matthews (1709-1791) (Mrs. Charles
Willson Peale, the artist's mother).
Peale painted a significant number of Quakers during his
lifetime, as he was very close to the Quaker community before he married Hannah
Moore. The Art Inventories Catalog, Smithsonian
American Art Museums lists a portrait of a Quaker woman, 1772, which is
"unlocated." See Peale's portrait of the Quaker Mrs. John Dickinson and daughter,
Sally, dated 1773, but probably executed in 1772, and the Quaker John
Cadwalader family, 1772 in which Mr. Cadwalader, his wife and child are
depicted. See discussion in Quaker
Esthetics, edited by Emma Jones Lapsansky and Anne A. Verplanck, p. 139, in
a topic entitled "Quakerism And Colonial Portraiture"
Mrs. John Dickinson and
daughter, Sally,
The
Cadwalader Family
Peale
painted other portraits of prominent Quaker friends. See, e.g.:
Portrait of William Bartram
(1739-1823) by Charles Willson Peale, 1808, who was a Quaker friend of Peale's
Timothy
Matlack
Peale
even included a Quaker woman in one of his largest and most famous paintings,
"The Artist in His Museum, 1822," in which: "One can also see a few
visitors. A father instructs his young son who is holding an open book in his
hands (the museum guidebook?). A Quaker woman stands startled and fearful in
front of a huge mastodon skeleton, the museum’s half-covered showpiece; and
in the far back is a man with his arms crossed (Emphasis added)." The Impossible Museum by Peter Friedl.
Note
2) Of the 4 great American portrait painters of the 18th century, who were born
in this country, Peale, Gilbert Stuart, Benjamin West and John Singleton
Copley, Stuart came to England in 1775 and remained in England as a successful
portrait painter, competing with artists such as Sir Joshua Reynolds, Thomas
Gainsborough and George Romney, until he returned to America in 1792, and engaging
in his very successful practice of portraiture in America, based significantly
on his numerous portraits of George Washington, West and Copley remained in
England for the rest of their lives and were successful portraitists and
history painters. In contrast, Peale returned to
America and settled in Annapolis, Maryland in 1770, after a
trip to England for the sole purpose of studying with West, beginning in 1767. Peale was a patriotic soldier in the American Revolution
and engaged in a very active portrait practice, painting portraits of Revolutionary
War leaders, such as Washington, Franklin, Jefferson, Hancock and Hamilton, and
other participants in the American Revolution, such as Thomas Fitzgerald (See
next Peale portrait lot) and of the early years of the United States. He never
left this country again.
Note
3) Per Wikipedia:
"A Renaissance
man, Peale had expertise not only in
painting but also in many diverse fields, including carpentry, dentistry, optometry, shoemaking, and taxidermy. In 1802, John Isaac Hawkins patented
the second official physiognotrace, a mechanical drawing device, and partnered with Peale to
market it to prospective buyers. Peale sent a watercolor sketch of the
physiognotrace, along with a detailed explanation, to Thomas
Jefferson. The drawing now sits with the
Jefferson Papers in the Library of Congress.[
Around
1804, Peale obtained the American patent rights to the polygraph from its inventor John Isaac Hawkins, about the same
time as the purchase of one by Thomas Jefferson. Peale and Jefferson
collaborated on refinements to this device, which enabled a copy of a
handwritten letter to be produced simultaneously with the original.
Peale
wrote several books, among which were An Essay on Building Wooden
Bridges (1797) and An Epistle to a Friend on the Means of
Preserving Health (1803). Peale named all of his sons for artists or
scientists, and taught them to paint. Three of them, Rembrandt, Raphaelle, and
Titian, became noted artists in their own right."
The
following Peale biographical materials are taken from the Askart.com website:
"Born in Chester, Maryland in
1741, Charles Willson Peale became one of the major figures in American art and
in other areas such as military figure, naturalist, curator, and inventor. He
developed an art and natural history museum that became world famous,
especially for the gallery of artwork that had his more than 250 portraits of
distinguished Americans. In his home, Peale charged admission to persons to see
his depictions of American heroes. By 1788, he opened a natural history museum
in Independence Hall in Philadelphia, and eventually accumulated over 100,000
items that included paintings, fossils, minerals, stuffed animals, and
skeletons.
In 1795, he opened his own art academy, which was not a success, and in 1805,
he became one of the founders of the Pennsylvania Academy.
His father was a schoolmaster who
died prematurely, and Charles grew up as the eldest son in Annapolis, Maryland
and helped support his widowed mother. He apprenticed in saddle making, silver
smithing, sign painting and portraiture, and had several lessons with painter
John Hesselius to whom he gave a saddle in exchange for instruction. He also
studied in Boston with portraitist and silversmith John Singleton Copley and
with painter John Smibert. When he returned to Maryland from his Boston
training, his talent was recognized by men who were planters and they raised
subscription money for him to study with expatriate history and portrait
painter, Benjamin West, in London. He also studied the Italian masters in
Italy. In 1769 he returned to Annapolis and there became an established
portraitist in the neo-classical style learned from Benjamin West. For
additional commissions, he traveled to Baltimore, Philadelphia, and
Williamsburg, Virginia and to Mount Vernon, home of George and Martha
Washington. In 1775, he moved to Philadelphia where he hoped to find more
portrait subjects. Shortly after, he joined the militia and fought with Washington
at the battles of Princeton and Trenton, and during this period created
miniatures of army personnel. In 1778, he settled in Philadelphia but continued
to visit Baltimore and the eastern shore of Maryland. From 1810 to 1821, he
lived as a gentleman farmer near Philadelphia but returned to the city in 1822
to take over the management of the Peale Museum. His fourteen portraits of
George Washington include the first authentic likeness of him and include seven
portraits painted from life. At Valley Forge where he was painting General
Washington, Peale also painted portraits of many other colonial leaders
including the Marquis de Lafayette. An outspoken anti-royalist, Peale served in
the Revolutionary War and alienated many of his wealthy patrons with their British
loyalties. From three marriages, he had three children, many whom became
artists. In 1827, Charles Peale died at age 86, the result of catching a cold
while crossing a body of water to court a woman."
Source: Michael David Zellman,
"300 Years of American Art;" Peter Falk, "Who Was Who in
American Art"
Per Askart.com, Peale’s works are
held in 61 museum collections, including almost all of the major American
museums.
Note 3) The foregoing considerations
and the following auction records regarding Peale sales warrant the conclusion that
the presale estimate of $30,000-$50,000 for this lot and the immediately
succeeding Peal portrait of Thomas Fitzgerald lot is reasonable and
justifiable.
Title/Subject: Thomas Willing Francis, 1794
Unsigned. Oil on canvas. 26
in. x 22 3/8 in. sold for $30,500 on 1/18/2011 at
Keno Auctions, NYC
Title/Subject: Mrs. Sarah Bordley Inscribed
and signed. Oil on canvas. in. 25 in. x 19.75 in. sold for $43,750 on 3/4/2010 at
Christie’s, NY
Title/Subject: Edward Burd (1751-1833), c. 1820 Signature information not
available. Oil on canvas. 28.50 in. x
23.25 in. sold for $40,000 on 11/14/2009-11/15/2009 at Brunk Auctions, Asheville,
NC
Title/Subject: James W. DePeyster, 1798 Signed and dated. Oil on canvas. 29.75 in. x 25 in. sold for $104,500 on 12/24/2008
at Christie’s, NY
Title/Subject: John Beale Bordley Signed.
Oil on canvas. 25.70 in. x 19.70 in. sold for $265,000 on 5/21/2008 at
Christie’s, NY
Title/Subject:
Margaret Galbraith Unsigned. Oil on canvas. 26 in. x 20.70 in.
sold for $37,000 on 01/18/2008-01/19/2008 at Sotheby’s, NY Title/Subject:
William Sansom Unsigned. Oil on canvas. 20.50 in. x 16.50 in. sold
for $37,000 on 01/18/2008-01/19/2008 at Sotheby’s, NY Title/Subject:
George Washington at Princeton Signed. Oil on canvas. 96.50 in. x 61.50 in.
sold for $21,296,000 on 1/21/2006 at Christie’s, NY Title/Subject:
James W. DePeyster, 1798 Signed. Oil on canvas. 29.70 in. x 25 in. sold for
$84,000 on 5/19/2005 at Christie’s, NY Title/Subject:
Elizabeth DePeyster Unsigned. Oil on canvas. 29.20 in. x 24 in.
sold for $57,500 on 10/9/2004 at Pook & Pook, Inc.,
Downingtown, PA Title/Subject:
George Washington Unsigned. Oil on canvas. 50 in. x 40 in.
sold for $6,167,500 on at Christie’s, NY |
|
|